Rewards of merit


This collection contains six hundred and six American and British-made rewards of merit dating between 1802 and 1900. Present are examples of early printing techniques used in Boston, New York, Newburyport, Lowell, and Providence; including chrome plating, lithography, embossing, chromolithography, lacework and woodblock printing. There are also merits handmade by teachers, such as the cut paper prize given to Miss Mary Dodge in 1826. In folder eleven, there is relevant correspondence sent between William Sumner Appleton and donors who contributed rewards of merit to Historic New England during the 1920-40s; the decades when the materials were accumulated most rapidly. We also possess numerous micro-collections; groups of rewards of merit given to a single pupil over a span of time, generally by one teacher.


Descriptive Terms

groups of animals
putti (motifs)
children (people by age group)
costume (mode of fashion)
cut-paper work
flowers (plants)
ice skating
industry (economic concept)
landscapes (environments)
men (male humans)
Native American
report cards
Sunday schools (institutions)
trains (vehicle groupings)
tops (toys)
women (female humans)
block printing (relief printing process)
rewards of merit

Physical Description

11 folders (1 box)

Finding Aid Info

An electronic finding aid is available through Historic New England's Collections Access Portal. A paper finding aid is available in the Library & Archives.

Custodial History

The materials were collected privately by individuals across New England and the United States, and later acquired piecemeal by Historic New England. The majority of the collection arrived at Historic New England by mail in the decade following the 1925 publication of Hattie Elliot Johnson's article “Old Time Rewards of Merit” in Old Time New England, which prompted public interest and donations. By this process Historic New England's collection of Rewards of Merit was formed, excepting occasional purchases by Appleton and others.

Collection Code


Collection Name

Ephemera collection

Reference Code



A collection of nineteenth century rewards of merit.


Amherst (Hillsborough county, New Hampshire)
Boston (Suffolk county, Massachusetts)
London (Greater London, England, United Kingdom)
Lowell (Middlesex county, Massachusetts)
Newburyport (Essex county, Massachusetts)
Providence (Providence county, Rhode Island)
Plymouth (Plymouth County, Massachusetts)

Record Details

Material Type

rewards of merit

Other People

Appleton, William Sumner, 1874-1947
Barr, Caroline Francis , 1835-1922
Baxter, Charles N.
Bowen, Abel, 1790-1850
Bowen, Henry, 1794-1874
Dodge, Mary
Lewis, George
Lord, Charlie
Norcross, Lucy Lane
Washington, George, 1732-1799

Other Organizations

Boston Latin School (Mass.)
Boston Primary School (Mass.)
Charles Whipple Bookseller of Newburyport
Cummings & Hilliard of Boston
Dobbs of London
E.P. Dutton & Co.
George Daniels Booksellers of Providence
Gibson Litho Co. of Cincinnati and New York
Jos. Laing & Co. of New York
Massachusetts Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Mayhew Grammar School of Boston
Nathaniel Orr & Co. of New York
N.S. Simpkins & Co. of Boston
Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, London
W. & J. Gilman of Newburyport
Young Ladies High School, Providence, Rhode Island


This collection is available for research.

Conservation Note

In 2016 materials were removed from acidic folders and where necessary inserted into protective Mylar sheets.


Delicate materials may be restricted due to their condition. There are no technical restrictions on this collection.

Description Level


Accruals Note

Accruals are expected.

Appraisal, Destruction, and Scheduling Note

Acidic envelopes original to the 1920s were photocopied and discarded in 2016.

Language Note

Materials are entirely in English.

Preferred Citation

Item identification. Box #, folder #. Rewards of Merit. Ephemera collection (EP001). Historic New England, Library & Archives.

Processing Information

This collection was processed by Kirsten Vega, 2016.

Rules and Conventions

This finding aid is DACS-compliant.

Related Items

Johnson, H. E. (1925). Old Time Rewards of Merit. Old Time New England, 16(1), 41st ser., 11-17.
Condon, L. (2012, Summer). History on Paper. Historic New England, 29.

Historical/Biographical Note

Historical/Biographical Note

The reward of merit is a small piece of paper given to school children for good behavior. Usually it features a pleasant image; whether decorated by hand, with watercolors, or chromolithography. The cards were used to commend regular attendance, exemplary deportment, studiousness and more. The practice of giving motivational rewards of merit to school children originated in America at the turn of the nineteenth century, and was practiced into the early twentieth; the decades which saw printer matter come into ubiquity.

Early on, teachers would hand-decorate tokens, sometimes awarding samples of their own calligraphy, but by the 1850s it had become more usual to purchase sheets of pre-fabricated rewards from local stationers. These had dotted lines for names and dates and almost always carried the headline “Reward of Merit”. As Maurice Rickards points out in Encyclopedia of Ephemera, “Reward-of-merit cards were a major sideline for the chromolithography industry; many commercial trade cards and personal calling card blanks required no greater adaption than the addition of the words 'Reward of Merit' in place of a name. The rewards of merit therefore reveal much about the printing industry, about its art, its audience, and its makers.

Alongside progress in printing was progress in education, as attendance laws began to mandate that children attend school regularly. Now faced with larger classrooms, some teachers sought effective means to motivate their students without copious physical discipline. Rewards of merit were a useful and inexpensive option. Especially in the early decades of the nineteenth century, poor and Puritanical homes tended to be free of decoration, and for this reason the vivid drawings on rewards of merit were highly desirable to children. Rewards of merit were also apt vehicles for moral messages: many carry biblical verses which were meant to be memorized and recited, and others have religious messages such as “Look to Jesus” or “Be kindly affectioned to one another”. Some rewards depict children roaming through graveyards; a scene intended to nudge pupils into mentally preparing for an early death. These and others were used in American Sunday schools.

In addition to bearing attractive pictures and moral messages, the reward of merit also functions as a receipt. It is proof that a student went to school for a time: something that made families proud. Perhaps this is why so many have survived for our examination.


Fenn, P., & Malpa, A. P. (1994). Rewards of merit: Tokens of a child's progress and a teacher's esteem as an enduring aspect of American religious and secular education. Schoharie, NY: Ephemera Society of America.
Hudson, G. S. (2008). The design & printing of ephemera in Britain & America, 1720-1920. London: British Library.
Johnson, H. E. (1925). Old Time Rewards of Merit. Old Time New England, 16(1), 41st ser., 11-17.
Pierce, S., Slautterback, C., & Barnhill, G. B. (1997). Early American lithography: Images to 1830. Boston, MA: Boston Athenaeum.
Rickards, M., Twyman, M., Beaumont, S. D., & Tanner, A. (2000). Reward of merit. In The encyclopedia of ephemera: A guide to the fragmentary documents of everyday life for the collector, curator, and historian (pp. 271-273). New York: Routledge.



The materials in this collection had no original order and are arranged chronologically and by decade. Folders IX through XI contain miscellaneous items which require separate folders due to their size or condition.

Reparative Language in Collections Records

Historic New England is committed to implementing reparative language description for existing collections and creating respectful and inclusive language description for new collections. If you encounter language in Historic England's Collections Access Portal that is harmful or offensive, or you find materials that would benefit from a content warning, please contact [email protected].